Wednesday, May 9, 2012

My Thoughts On "The Hunger Games".

Before I get to the "meat" of this post, I want to make a few points. This is about The Hunger Games the book, not the movie. I have not seen the movie and do not intend to until it has either come onto Netflix or is available from Red Box. This is not a paid review/endorsement, etc. This is just my opinion and view of the series, although I have only read the first book and the second Catching Fire.

Now, I know it seems as if I have jumped on the pop-culture bandwagon, and perhaps I have in a way. I first heard about The Hunger Games through a friend, a fellow Mama. Her 16 year old daughter had read the series and convinced my friend to read them. My friend really enjoyed them, said she couldn't put them down. I thought the whole concept seemed a bit nuts, nothing I was interested in. Then somehow or another I heard that they had made the first book into a movie, and some other friends, and fellow Mama's were reading the books because their kiddos had asked to read them/see the movie. So, I figured that I had better read the book in case my kiddos asked to read/see. Big mistake! Not in a bad way, but because I really enjoyed the first 2 books of the series and find my mind wandering to the themes and concepts of the book frequently. I will be getting to these dwellings soon, after I get a chance to say write a bit more.

First, I am very glad I read them because my youngest son, a 10 year old 4th grader, asked if he could read it and I could give an educated answer. No, not yet. I don't think he is ready for it. Many of his classmates have read it and some may have seen the movie, but I just think it's a bit early for my kids. But in another 2 years for him, perhaps. Maybe even 3 years. And while my kiddos are reading the books, I will be re-reading them with the kids so that we can discuss things, because I happen to think that there are so many topics worth talking about in this series.

Secondly, I do like the books. They are very entertaining, yes, but as I said before, they can be a springboard for discussions with your kids (and others!) on so many topics. (I will get to those, I promise!!) The mix of primitive living with futuristic high tech  world of this series is very interesting, and surprisingly easy to imagine. There is violence, yes, but I don't feel that it is unnecessarily violent or gory, considering the context of the books. I have the feeling that the movie may be more gory than the books. There is a romantic element in The Hunger Games and even more so in Catching Fire, which is very appealing to me, a hopeless romantic. (Admittedly, I am Team Peeta!) The themes of family, friendship, survival, doing what is right, responsibility, and love make you wonder what you would do in the character's places.

So, as promised, here are those topics in which I feel you can explore with your children (There could be some spoiler alerts!):
  1. Wild Edibles: After the death of her father, Katniss Everdeen, her mother and younger sister nearly die of starvation. Her mother is locked in a depression so crippling she is unable to care for her daughters. After spotting some dandelions, Katniss realizes that she has the knowledge to feed her family with wild plants, knowledge passed on to her by her father. Why not learn about wild edible plants in your area with your children, making a journal with pictures of them?
  2. Healing Plants and Herbs: Katniss' mother is a healer, having knowledge of what plants and herbs are useful for what ailments. This knowledge is handed down to Katniss' younger sister, Prim, who seems to have the "healing touch." Again, find out more about this, recording it in a journal.
  3. Hunting and Trapping Wild Game: Again, this is knowledge handed down to Katniss by her father, as well as learning from her friend, Gale. Katniss uses a bow and arrow for hunting, while Gale has a talent for snares. In the annual Hunger Games, other silent but fatal weapons are used, unfortunately on other youngsters, but the kids have this knowledge because of the kind of wildlife they have in their own district. Spears, knives, swords and even tridents are used. Perhaps you could learn a new skill with your kids, such as archery or even using a slingshot. Fishing is another recreation that can be wonderful family time, and just think: fresh fish for dinner!
  4. Children as Weapons: As unpleasant and revolting as it is, the Hunger Games of the book are used to keep the people in their places, reminding them that they are in the control of a society that will take and kill their children. Even more revolting  and sad is the truth that this is not just a concept for novels and movies, but a startling reality. Think about the wars in Uganda, where children were stolen from their homes and villages, the boys to become child soldiers, the girls suffering rape, disease and motherhood while still children themselves.
  5. Dictators: Although the ruler in this series is called President Snow, there is never any mention of voting. The truth is he is a ruthless dictator, killing and/or punishing any who oppose him and his ideas. Sound familiar? Think of the history lessons you can tie in here.
  6. Self Sacrifice: Katniss becomes a tribute for the Hunger Games after volunteering to take her sister's place. However, her sacrifice begins when she assumes the role of bread winner (literally!) and provider after her father's death. Peeta, too, sacrifices his own welfare many times in favor of Katniss. Discuss this with your kids, and maybe look in the Bible for scripture about this topic.
  7. Breaking the Law: We teach our children to follow the rules and that it is wrong to break the law, but what of the laws are unjust and in place to slowly starve you? Katniss repeatedly breaks the law by going hunting and gathering outside of District 12's fence, selling some of the game at the local black market and keeping the rest to feed her family. What does the Bible say about government and keeping it's laws?
  8. Alcoholism: Katniss' and Peeta's mentor in the games is Haymitch, former tribute and victor of the Hunger Games. He is also an alcoholic. The emotional toll of being a Hunger Games victor is huge, and he turns to alcohol to escape the nightmares. Is that an excuse, certainly not, but understandable. We all have something we turn to for comfort, some healthy, some not. What/who can we turn to for comfort? How can you avoid alcohol/drug abuse?
  9. Romance: I use this for lack of a better term, but it is a completely relevant topic. There is kissing in the first book, talk of being wildly in love. In the second book there is more kissing and the emotions and feelings that can cause and result from kissing. Peeta and Katniss also sleep in the same bed, although there is no hanky-panky, they are fully clothed and I don't believe that any kissing takes place during these encounters. The romance is very G/PG rated, but it is the emotions involved that can be discussed, as well as if it is permissible for Katniss and Peeta to be sharing a bed. What about the love triangle of Katniss, Peeta and Gale?
  10. Drinking Water: We all need water to survive, but do we know how to acquire it? Do we know how to purify it? In the first book, Katniss uses iodine to purify her drinking water. In the second book (SPOILER ALERT) Katniss saves the day when she recognizes a spile from her knowledge of maple sugaring. She is able to get drinkable water from the trees that surround her.

    So, that is my take on The Hunger Games series. It could be so easy to see our kids get caught up in the pop culture of the books and movie, but I feel that they are popular with good reason. They resonate with anyone with a self-reliant, self-sustaining, preparedness streak. They have certainly made me think about what knowledge I have and need to attain in the areas of wild edibles, healing plants, first aid and drinking water, as well as renewed my interest in archery.
    I whole heartily suggest that parents read this series, or at least the first book, to decide if they are appropriate for their children, and by no means do you need to wait for them to read them to address the above topics, but I know how it can be with children. Sometimes they need an outside influence to whet their appetites for things you would like to teach them, and I feel that this could be a tool.

    Many blessings, (and may the odds be in your favor! ;D)
    Kelly




6 comments:

  1. I'm so glad to have read this post today! My daughter asked about reading the first book (she is 13) so we are on the library's waiting list at number 11. I've been wondering at the mature sounding themes and whether I should have agreed or not. I do plan to read it first, though she reads much faster and may end up finishing before I do. Thank you for taking to the time to detail topics in the format you did!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm so glad this helped you! I hope that you both enjoy reading these books. I'm really looking forward to when my kiddos are of an age to read these. Of course, by then, they may not want to! Thanks for stopping in and for taking the time to leave a comment!
      Blessings,
      Kelly

      Delete
  2. Hi! I saw this and had to read your review, and I think you bring up some great talking points to use with kids! I read the books and saw the movie, and thought the movie did a great job of not portraying any gratuitous violence. It also really harnessed the seriousness and emotion of what was happening; I was literally holding my breath during the reaping scene. It was very, very real, and a slap-in-the-face for the audience because this could, does, and did happen (e.g., Ancient Rome).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, Laura, for stopping in. I'm glad you liked the review and gave me a heads up on the movie. I was a bit concerned, and even though I'm an adult, I still like to be careful about what I watch!
      Blessings,
      Kelly

      Delete
  3. I think one of the greatest topics that this book leads to is the ethics of media: "Reality" TV and it's effects on society, desensitization, control of info through media, control of society's beliefs/fears/actions through media . . . It goes on. But in such a stylized and extreme example, it really parallels so many of these topics in our own society, and it's a great way to open the discussion with teenagers to the power of what they choose as tv, movies, books, music, etc.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you Rachel, you are absolutely right. I kept thinking of more and more topics as I wrote my review, and it could have gone on forever! I was thinking that the control of the media wnt along with the dictatirship, but you are right on about "reality" shows and the effects of media on our lives. Thank you again for sharing, and thanks for stopping in.
      Blessings,
      Kelly

      Delete